just saw this the other night, and it was quite funny. it had all the elements for disaster but the jokes were executed really well I thought. the second half got a little slow, but the poke at Brian Wilson, Elvis, and Bob Dylan were hilarious.

not crap.
I'd go see it again.

jack white was elvis.

how weird is that?

was Jon Spencer free?

(wait, I should rephrase that . . .)

why didn't they use Jon Spencer?

Gareth Keenan wrote:was Jon Spencer free?

(wait, I should rephrase that . . .)

why didn't they use Jon Spencer?

Because he's a rip-off of Jerry Lee Lewis, not Elvis. :)

Looks horrendous. I will not be seeing this.

Terrible.

Just because Apatow writes a movie does not mean it should be made.

I found it drawn out and just not that funny. The jokes rehashed that kind of "dirty-things-are-edgy-never-gratuitous" humor that plagues so many American comedies these days.

i'm in no hurry to see this and the more i hear about it , the less i want to.

Looks worth renting and that's it.

i might see it, but i'm not going out of my way to,

Sub-shit. Sub-Sandler. Unrated cut is slightly better but with that cast, this should have been a masterpiece. Seriously, was this written over a weekend?

Waffles: The Lil' Nutsack thing and the some of the extended Brian Wilson stuff were the only audible laughs it got out of me. Good thing I didn't see this in the theater because I would have been out of the door by the time the midget protest song started.