Do you have absolute pitch?

Yes
Total votes: 7 (23%)
No
Total votes: 23 (77%)
Total votes: 30

Do you have absolute pitch

21
Arson Smith wrote:I wouldn't call it 'perfect pitch', but if I go to my buddy's house and pick up his guitar (which he will insist is perfectly in tune) my ear can usually determine within 2 to 3 Black Sabbath riffs whether the whole guitar happens to be tuned down a half-step or more.

Whether I like it or not, through repeated exposure I can pretty much play back the first side of 'Paranoid' in my head like a tape recorder. Knowing that, I can fumble through getting the guitar tuned to almost 'concert pitch', A=440Hz, whatever you want to call it.

So it's slightly better than nothing, but I wouldn't call it 'perfect pitch' just yet because I can't exactly call out names of notes as they're played.

But maybe 'absolute pitch' is the best way to put it... for example, if I end up at karaoke at the bar down the street with my co-worker Pat, she will always want to do 'Piece Of My Heart' but she will ask to have the pitch brought down by the Karaoke Jockey (KJ?) which absolutely sets my teeth on edge, even though she sings the song perfectly well within the relative key.


That's interesting, because I think absolute pitch is partly innate and partly a matter of ëxercise- it's like a muscle in that if it isn't used alot, it gets soft and weak. These days since I really don't play music as much as I used to, the whole process of identification takes longer. However, when I was 20 and jammed in a band 4 days a week, I could literally hear something- anything and could visualize how to play it on the guitar in seconds. I can do this still, but it takes more time and concentration and I'm sure if I began playing more it would become easier.

Do you have absolute pitch

22
isn't the perfect pitch the ability to not only tune a instrument but also correctly name every note? and btw, what is an margin of error a person with perfect pitch is allowed to to make in detecting the difference between two frequencies? as for me, i can tune a guitar without a tuner but i can't play a song from a cd, stop it in any given moment, and say "the last note was, she was an A#".

Do you have absolute pitch

23
the perfect pitch is a sort of Synesthesia. either you have it or you don't. I don't think you can learn it. well I'm far away from it. I just hear when things are out of tune and I can tell major cords from minor cords. when I get new strings I always make the first tuning by "listening". sometimes I get pretty close to it....but yeah... far away from the perfect pitch.

the funny thing is that people who have a perfect pitch on 440 Hz get very confused if you tune a piano on 438 Hz. I also assume that the perfect pitch can be a torment in a world full of stupid music ring tones radios tv shows .

Do you have absolute pitch

24
emmanuelle cunt wrote:isn't the perfect pitch the ability to not only tune a instrument but also correctly name every note? and btw, what is an margin of error a person with perfect pitch is allowed to to make in detecting the difference between two frequencies? as for me, i can tune a guitar without a tuner but i can't play a song from a cd, stop it in any given moment, and say "the last note was, she was an A#".
Imagine you would see tones in different colors. A# is green for example. so yes you would know that it's A# if you had a perfect pitch.

Do you have absolute pitch

25
emmanuelle cunt wrote:isn't the perfect pitch the ability to not only tune a instrument but also correctly name every note? and btw, what is an margin of error a person with perfect pitch is allowed to to make in detecting the difference between two frequencies? as for me, i can tune a guitar without a tuner but i can't play a song from a cd, stop it in any given moment, and say "the last note was, she was an A#".


Yes it is. However, the names given to musical tones are purely arbitrary really-- just a matter of history and convention. It's the ability to hear and replicate what is heard that really matters.

I can take a Waterford goblet and do the old wet finger thing and name the fundamental and harmonics in it or what they are approximately. Obviously a Waterford goblet is not a musical instrument so it is not engineered to resonate in reference to 440 Hz necessarily, but when I do the wet finger thing I can tell what the tones are close to.

The funny thing is this: 440 Hz is a purely arbitrary thing.

Do you have absolute pitch

28
newberry wrote:If you walked into a room without a piano or other reference, and you belted out an A note into a chromatic tuner, how close to 440 would you be? Have you tried this?


I haven't but I should. I've just been singing the note (after a long enough period of not hearing it), then tuning my 5th string to the pitch, plugging into the tuner and seeing where it is. I'm generally not far off, I need to get the fine tuning down, but I haven't done any proper frequency analysis as I am without soundcard at the moment.

Do you have absolute pitch

29
petercobber wrote:Having, and actually telling people that you have, perfect pitch is like having, and telling people you have, a perfect cock...you likely don't have one, and those that do, usually don't feel compelled to talk about it. They are usually too busy fucking.


Ha - this is great!
"The best argument against democracy is a five minute conversation with the average voter."
-Winston Churchill

Do you have absolute pitch

30
I bought a perfect pitch audio course about 15 years ago. This guy says that anyone can have the perfect pitch, but of course he waits until he has your money to tell you how much fucking work it takes. I still haven't gone through all the tapes. Guess I'm not hungry enough.

Has anyone gotten their perfect pitch with the help of a similar course?

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 333 guests