424
by TheCajunKitchen_Archive
Well, im gonna be a bitch and not read the entire thread before I post.
"The intelligent design debate is a fun one to have...in a philosophy classroom. Not in a science classroom. The end."
As a philosophy student I find that statement extremely offensive and arrogant... Sure, the intelligent design debate is fun to have in a philosophy classroom... full of retarded monkeys spewing shit around - that must be fun.
Dont get me wrong, its fine to be religious - as long as one is it for personal reasons.
"Gott ist Tot" (God is dead) - that line indicates the end of "onto-theo-logics" in philosophical thinking (if people listened to philosophers, it would be the end in thinking in general). Often the sentence is believed to some sort of victory - that Nietzsche, the self-proclaimed anti-christ succeeded in killing God. That is not the case. In "die fröhliche wissenschaft" (the gay science), it is described as a catastrophy, but also in a describtive way - God is no longer, as a serious being, present in the conscienceness of man and nihilism and meaninglessness is dominant.
The reason why God can not be discussed in the same way as before Gods death, or even before that after Kant, is that God historically changes his/her/its relation to mankind, and from Kant and on, being (almost) completely seperated, as a "Ding an Sich" (thing in itself).
This downfall of God, from a omnipresent perfect being to a "Ding an Sich" and lastly as only an echo, is often seen in the light of the theodice-problem, literally meaning the problem of Gods justice. In its most simple (and most flawed) form, it goes: How can an all-powerfull, all-knowing and all-good allow apparent evil to exist? Well there are to answers: either God isnt all-powerfull etc. at least one of the three God is not, in which case God is not perfect, or: Everything is good all the time always. In both cases to believe in God leads to extreme apathy, either you have to put your trust and prayer and hopes at a less than perfect being, whom might as well be a deamon, or you might as well kill youself, since everything that happens/is the case by definition is good.
God have been dissolved as a giver of meaning. The only way being religious is meaningfull is for ones own personal reasons and happiness - hence it is meaningless to talk about intelligent design.