sleepkid wrote:Has someone ever done a "Goat" vs "Liar" which is better? thread?

Cunningham wrote:Goat is better than Liar, but Liar has "slave ship" so... its a tie. "Head" makes me wanna strangle myself with a belt while spankin' it. I really like that record.

Here is a thread for you.

Cunningham wrote:Goat is better than Liar, but Liar has "slave ship" so... its a tie. "Head" makes me wanna strangle myself with a belt while spankin' it. I really like that record.

Listen to some Scratch Acid, that stuff is wayyyy more reminiscent of The Birthday Party than the Jesus Lizard.

Liar has "Gladiator" on it, which pretty much rendered me useless on the drums for a while, as after I first heard it, I didn't play anything else for a week or two. And even now whenever I sit down at a drum kit, it's one of the first things I play to warm up.

Chapter Two wrote:Here is a thread for you.

Thanks for the link to the thread.

Liar and Goat are both amazing. Interesting to see who rated which one better. Head is not to be discounted either. I own everything up to Blue on vinyl. (Don't own Blue at all.) Plus just about everything Scratch Acid did as well. Some of the most vital music of the last 20 years. But talking about that here is mostly just preaching to the choir, innit?

(oh, and as an aside Chapter Two, think Southgate'll do the job for you?)

sleepkid wrote:

Chapter Two wrote:Here is a thread for you.

Thanks for the link to the thread.

Liar and Goat are both amazing. Interesting to see who rated which one better. Head is not to be discounted either. I own everything up to Blue on vinyl. (Don't own Blue at all.) Plus just about everything Scratch Acid did as well. Some of the most vital music of the last 20 years. But talking about that here is mostly just preaching to the choir, innit?

(oh, and as an aside Chapter Two, think Southgate'll do the job for you?)

You were already deep in an aside.

I'm afraid I'm not knowledgeable enough football-wise to make a judgement on Gareth Southgate's potential as a manager. I hope so though. Cheers.

american hardcore by far.

hmmm.

gang of four, the fall, wire, joy division, slits, x-ray spex.
minor threat, minutemen, meat puppets, husker du, big black.

too tough to call.

Brett Eugene Ralph wrote:The Fall vs. Void: Yanks win, 4-4

no

Brett Eugene Ralph wrote:Sex Pistols vs. Bad Brains: Yanks win, 10-7

no

Brett Eugene Ralph wrote:The Slits vs. Meat Puppets: Yanks win, 11-9

no


And how about PiL vs. Pere Ubu? I'd have to go with PiL.

Brits win.

bad brains were a lot better than the sex pistols in my mind.

i agree that the fall vs. void comparison is absurd. you'd have to give it to the fall for the sheer quantity of great releases from 1979-83. void had like twenty minutes of material at most right? doesn't really seem fair.

tommydski wrote:bad brains were a lot better than the sex pistols in my mind.

Objectively speaking, I can't see how the Sex Pistols could lose to anyone on a punk list. I mean, they invented the shit.

same wrote:

tommydski wrote:bad brains were a lot better than the sex pistols in my mind.

Objectively speaking, I can't see how the Sex Pistols could lose to anyone on a punk list. I mean, they invented the shit.

i'm kinda new here, so i don't really know all the member personas, but this is an obvious joke right?

same wrote:Objectively speaking, I can't see how the Sex Pistols could lose to anyone on a punk list. I mean, they invented the shit.

is that like the monkees were the band the beatles could have been?

surely you mean the ramones fellah.