Reeds in rock music

crap
Total votes: 13 (30%)
not crap
Total votes: 31 (70%)
Total votes: 44

instrumentation: sax-clarinets in rock music

55
that damned fly wrote:the rock music with sax that sucks i think would suck anyway, with or without the sax.


Agreed.

Not a big fan of the Sax to begin with, but I absolutely adore the clarinet family. Though I don't care for the idea of them in a band being overpowered by guitars and drums. They sound much better left unamplified.

This is the greatest piece of music ever written for clarinet

In rock music: Totally dependent. Perhaps NOT CRAP?
Marsupialized wrote:Right now somewhere nearby there is a fat video game nerd in his apartment fucking a pretty hot girl he met off craigslist. God bless that craig and his list.

instrumentation: sax-clarinets in rock music

56
The people that typically know how to write, perform and record rock music with it's instrumentation of the last 30-40 years (drums, guitars, vox) aren't consistently skilled at writing for, performing, or recording the saxes or clarinets. It's always hit or miss, usually miss with the saxes just sounding embarrassing. I've been in sessions where everything is sounds great and was deliberately made so...and then they get me in there and all they know is that they want saxophone. No parts, no idea, no nothing.

Most of the saxes playing beside Little Richard make me want to explode with glee. Funhouse is good too, but the sax could be better. Sonny Rollins' solo on that Rolling Stones song shifts the song from annoying to awesome in the final moments.

Oh yea, Sonny Rollins is the best thing to blow through a conical-bored instrument ever made. Period. PERIOD.

I like that sax scene in the movie Lost Highway.

I'd rather get stung by a wasp than have to listen to Beefheart pretend to play the saxophone.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests