gotdamn wrote: Sat Jul 26, 2025 3:40 pm
Plenty of great music in the "hot" 20's, but it'd be odd to prefer that to the later evolutions of the quintet etc. I remember being astounded by Louis Armstrong's playing in the Hot Five and Hot Seven recordings, especially having grown up knowing his vocal stuff (which is great music, but weirdly sounds older than his 20's material!)
Every song featuring Eddie Lang on guitar is fire.
There's a real sweet spot in the late 1910's and early 20's where country music and jazz music share the same primordial soup. Emmett Miller to Jimmie Rodgers to Hank Sr. isn't even a stretch - maybe that's too "musicologist" based to enjoy for its own merits, like one would the 50's-70's stuff, but it's fascinating listening nonetheless. After the development of the phonograph, American culture evolved quickly and covered its tracks. It went from minstrel show 78s to what Lee Morgan called black classical music within a generation!
Yeah Man I voted Hot Jazz without having to think too hard about it. And I love a lot of jazz. Those Hot Fives and Sevens, Django Reinhardt and Stephanie Grappeli, Bix Beiderbecke. These guys made music that punches me straight in the fuckin' head. Funny, wild, bursting at the seams. Love it so much. Get the Penguin Jazz Guide, find any record in the 20's and 30's , I'm having a great time.
I love bebop, hard bop, sure man. Post Bop? Is that Miles' tuneless mid 60's stuff? I don't get that at all!
The hardest part here is how much I love Thelonious Monk. Hard to quantify which of these guys make me happier to be alive, but my gut says Hot, so that's that.
Fusion leaves me cold but I keep trying, man. Maybe one day.