Photograph of a Thunder-Dome: Which band is "better"

Imagine Dragons
Total votes: 10 (83%)
Nickelback
Total votes: 2 (17%)
Total votes: 12

Re: Either/Or: Imagine Dragons vs. Nickelback

21
Krev wrote: Mon Feb 16, 2026 4:04 pm Puddle of Mud's biggest hit ripped off the progression from "I Saw your Mommy" by Suicidal Tendencies. I remember hearing that shit song on the radio.
And made it some misogynistic piece of shit, correct!

I think "Blurry" was a bigger hit, and not a terrible song. Still, of all the bands to rip off . . . like signing up to be in that back of human centipede. That's Nickelback.

Re: Either/Or: Imagine Dragons vs. Nickelback

23
pldms wrote: This discussion has been a revelation. It transpires that I had conflated Imagine Dragons with DragonForce, and have never heard a note of the former's oeuvre, nor even seen a picture of them.
Dude I came here to say this!

I know they're different bands but I've only heard DragonForce, so in my mind Imagine Dragons is like D-Force* mixed with a little Muse.




*to be confused with D-War
Escape Rope / Black Mesa / Inflatable Sex Babies

Re: Either/Or: Imagine Dragons vs. Nickelback

27
jfv wrote: Sun Feb 15, 2026 8:10 pm this is really happening??

Nickelback loses to almost everyone. Except maybe Kid Rock.
Some of you could, at the very least, attempt to act like you have a half a clue some of the time.

I probably have "The Entire Board Versus Me Solo..." faded when it comes to listening to both of these bands.

Nickleback could have eighty-six arms, and it would stand no chance of touching this -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMKfIXd ... rt_radio=1

(Seriously, Uncle Kracker is a goof and he is going off like it the the sun is about to explode...)

Never mind the time Creepy Band covered that tune while getting into arguments and switching instruments only to patch hings up and kick into it when each member was on his original instrument.

Empty Bottle. Total "PRF MkI" moment.

So, yeah...

Killin' me, Smalls...

Re: Either/Or: Imagine Dragons vs. Nickelback

29
I guess of the 2, Imagine Dragons is 'better'. I don't recall enjoying any of their music, but Nickelback is just...joyless.

FTR, I bought Devil Without A Cause back when it was popular, I liked Kid Rock at the time. (Robert Christgau compared the album to License to Ill. I agree with that.) But that was a long time ago, I could not have predicted he'd become what he is now.
"Whatever happened to that album?"
"I broke it, remember? I threw it against the wall and it like, shattered."

Re: Either/Or: Imagine Dragons vs. Nickelback

30
gotdamn wrote: Mon Feb 16, 2026 5:17 pm
Krev wrote: Mon Feb 16, 2026 4:04 pm Puddle of Mud's biggest hit ripped off the progression from "I Saw your Mommy" by Suicidal Tendencies. I remember hearing that shit song on the radio.
And made it some misogynistic piece of shit, correct!

I think "Blurry" was a bigger hit, and not a terrible song. Still, of all the bands to rip off . . . like signing up to be in that back of human centipede. That's Nickelback.
Yeah, it traded Mike Muir's humorous wordplay about having your mom whacked for base-level dipshit.
I'd rather be throwing darts.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests