A marvellous lecturer and a deeply fascinating topic.Gramsci wrote: Sun Mar 01, 2026 1:12 pmOh, very much my thing. Thanks for sharing.Dovira wrote: Sun Mar 01, 2026 6:19 am Not reading but listening to these two lectures of Isaiah Berlin on German philosophy. Fantastic stuff.
In this context it's interesting to think of the duality of Marx, of whom I am ambivalent and apprehensive while I can't deny his actuality. The intellectual milieu which shapes him and which he makes his own is at the same time the near-despotic Enlightenment techno-futurism of total rational organization, and this kind of extremely radical individualism - 'freedom' as not a certain kind of ordered life made possible by the proper delineation of rights to already-constituted subjects, but the very power that creates the subject, a principle of being, a spirit that seeks to break out of its confines ('fetters on production').
In a similar way, how the restrained, sober, regular, buttoned-up outward character of German Pietism nonetheless, due to its central components of self-reliance, self-relation and sentimental simplicity, can find stirring within it this kind of absolute craziness.
Once more showing the difficulty in establishing the causal power of ideas, and determining thereby which ones are "safe" and which ones are "dangerous", if such a thing can at all be done.